Roguelikes and I generally don't mix. I find that their narratives aren't compelling to me - the endless cavalcade of new generated rooms, layouts and spaces without distinct purpose. I have yet to find one that I find artistically provocative. Unfortunately, Cinco Paus feels about as basic as they come.

It's impressive how it all comes together. The premise is that you get five different wands with randomized effects each time you play, and you don't know what the effects are until you use the wands and see them in action. Each enemy has a different amount of health, and attacking them while adjacent to them deals damage to you as well. Each room is like a puzzle of experimentation. I will say, though, that's a bit hard to parse what the wand effects do - the game doesn't really tell you what the symbols mean and it can be easy to forget.

But those core mechanics are the only mildly interesting thing about this game. There is nothing underneath them, they aren't telling me anything about anything other than themselves. It's really a shame, I was interested in this game because I'd never heard about it before! But the core gameplay loop just feels like a distilled roguelike experience, even moreso than the average roguelike - which is not a compliment. What is the point of a strong set of systems when those systems aren't in service of anything else? I don't know. Maybe you can figure that point out for yourself, but for me, it's just not interesting.

Reviewed on Dec 25, 2022


2 Comments


1 year ago

Brough's work in general is usually like this, with the intent of having a simple realm of procedural challenges to mull over. It's more than likely as you're saying the RLs in general are just not for you, which is fine! I myself love them, though it's complicated. But I think one thing worth considering is that games like this, as an experience, in my view are almost more comparable to games like Tetris. This sort of procedural, simplistic gauntlet that you can just kinda sally forth into endlessly

1 year ago

Yeah, I omly played this because someone wanted me to review it - it was a unique experience at least! I'm just not much a fan of simplistic gauntlet type games