I feel bad rating it this low because on my first playthrough it genuinely felt like one of the better games I had played, but to me it offers almost zero replayability. The side quests are menial, the shrines are bland and demonstrably simple and there are just so many of them, a lot of them are just straight up clones. the world just feels dead on a second playthrough, it loses all the magic it had when i was new to the world and everything was fresh. its awfully balanced to the point where you have to limit yourself just to have fun (im looking at you, great fairies). I've tried several times to play it again but to no avail, I just get bored. The NPCs dont help because they all just say the same one line, some of them have one funny interaction that never changes.

TL;DR, for a first playthrough its pretty good, but offers little for replayability. has damning flaws in the form of shrines and npc behavior.