13 Lists

Super Meat Boy
Vanquish
Fallout: New Vegas
Shank
VVVVVV

Best of 2010

10 Games

Portal 2
Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3
L.A. Noire
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
Bastion

Best of 2011

10 Games

Fez
FTL: Faster Than Light
Thirty Flights of Loving
Journey
Super Hexagon

Best of 2012

10 Games

Gunpoint
Papers, Please
The Last of Us
Kentucky Route Zero
Lethal League

Best of 2013

10 Games

Duck Game
Crypt of the NecroDancer
Transistor
Alien: Isolation
NeoTokyo

Best of 2014

10 Games

The Beginner's Guide
Rocket League
Life is Strange
Downwell
Nuclear Throne

Best of 2015

10 Games

Quadrilateral Cowboy
The Witness
Firewatch
Inside
Doom

Best of 2016

10 Games

Hollow Knight
Super Mario Odyssey
The Norwood Suite
Cuphead
Sonic Mania

Best of 2017

10 Games

ZeroRanger
Into the Breach
Celeste
Return of the Obra Dinn
Lethal League Blaze

Best of 2018

10 Games

Outer Wilds
Dirt Rally 2.0
Metal Wolf Chaos XD
A Short Hike
Hades

Best of 2019

10 Games

Umurangi Generation
Half-Life: Alyx
The Last of Us Part II
The Pathless
Doom Eternal

Best of 2020

10 Games

Before Your Eyes
Cruelty Squad
Adios
Sable
Guilty Gear: Strive

Best of 2021

10 Games