2006

Runner Ups
Mega Man Powered Up
New Super Mario Bros
Pac Man World Rally

2007
Runner Ups
Super Mario Galaxy
No More Heroes
Sonic Rush Adventure
The World Ends with You

2008

Runner Ups
Super Smash Bros Brawl
Mario Kart Wii
Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity
Bully: Scholarship Edition
Kirby Super Star Ultra
Mega Man 9

Also shout outs to Sonic Chronicles being the worst game ever made

2009
Runner Ups
New Super Mario Bros Wii
InFamous
Mario & Sonic at the Winter Olympic Games DS

2010
Runner Ups
Mega Man 10
Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse
Scott Pilgrim Vs the World
Spider Man: Shattered Dimensions

2011

Runner Ups
InFamous 2
de Blob 2
Minecraft
Batman Arkham City
Rayman Origins

2012

Runner Ups
None lmao 2012 was sorta mid

2013
Runner Ups
Luigi's Mansion 2
Lego City: Undercover Cop
Rayman Legends

2014
Runner Ups
Another mid year

2015

Runner up
Super Mario Maker but kinda another year (Dragon Ball Z: Xenoverse maybe for nostalgia I guess)

2016
(Though was officially translated in 2017 but whatever, kinda another mid year)

Runner Up
Kirby Planet Robobot

2017
Runner Ups
Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle
Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga DX

2018
Runner Up
Mega Man 11

2019
Runner Ups
Shovel Knight: Treasure Trove

2020
Runner Up
Rayman Redemption

2021
This is the only exception I'm allowing, the new games I played were terrible so I'm counting this, my runner up would be Sam & Max Beyond Space and Time

2022
Runner Up
Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of Hope