Maybe my standards were affected by experiencing the original Sonic the Hedgehog on only an iPhone touch screen for many years, but my playthrough on the PS2’s Mega Collection Plus version was pretty enjoyable.

It’s an exceptionally simple platformer, even by 1991 design, but Sonic 1 has moments in every level that really capture a sense of speed from loop-de-loops, bumpers, and springs. During the times that you’re really moving fast, taking damage isn’t actually a huge penalty because you always have a few seconds to regain some of your health after a hit. Holding onto enough rings to enter the special stages at the end of a stage requires a lot of planning and can fall into trial-and-error territory. However, the whole game also has a great soundtrack and level aesthetics, which helps out the slower-paced Marble Zone and Labyrinth Zone a lot. With how short and easy the game (if you’re not focused on getting all the Master Emeralds), it’s an essential experience for those interested in video game history.

I think that Sonic makes much more sense as an armadillo though.

Reviewed on Dec 27, 2022


4 Comments


1 year ago

I like that Sonic 1 deliberately has moments that slow the gameplay out and this was by design, I don't really buy that the play experience is meant to accentuate speed necessarilly and I think it's one of the biggest misconceptions many fans have. I truly enjoy Marble and Labyrinth zone because they engage a different kind of playing skill, that being precision platforming and a no small bit of puzzle solving and logistics(esp for air bubbles), and ask for a lot of patience.

Another mark in Sonic for me is that I love that every game in the series has followed a thematic progression for their levels. Like forest level, water level, fire level, ice level, city level, etc. Obviously Mario 3 did this first(and I'm trying to think of earlier examples), but for me it was the Sonic games that really turned this into a trope. It's always been my favourite trope in video games growing up.

1 year ago

Yeah I actually like how the air system in Labyrinth Zone gives an extra challenge in navigating some rooms as fast as possible while offering bubbles as a spot to literally take a breather.

5 months ago

"I think that Sonic makes much more sense as an armadillo though."

Mighty fans where u at

5 months ago

Right here! 👊😤👌