Hotdog
Bio
For a game to get a five they have to be a game I truly love. Each one of the 5s listed have had a major impact on me at pivotal points in my life and their scores relfect that. My ratings are very personal and not objective at all. I have tastes that have been forged through decades of playing games religiously and those experiences have molded me and my tastes into what they are today. I don't think any game is perfect so for a game to get a five there needs to be a strong personal connection for me to rate it that highly!
For a game to get a five they have to be a game I truly love. Each one of the 5s listed have had a major impact on me at pivotal points in my life and their scores relfect that. My ratings are very personal and not objective at all. I have tastes that have been forged through decades of playing games religiously and those experiences have molded me and my tastes into what they are today. I don't think any game is perfect so for a game to get a five there needs to be a strong personal connection for me to rate it that highly!
Badges
Elite Gamer
Played 500+ games
Gamer
Played 250+ games
N00b
Played 100+ games
Favorite Games
685
Total Games Played
000
Played in 2024
224
Games Backloggd
Recently Reviewed See More
This is a game I never thought I would ever try to review. My number 1 hangup with trying to tackle a review of this game can be sumerized in many different ways...
is it possible to put to words the feelings of a seven year old playing this game for the first time as he drove along the Portuguese countryside with his parents in the early 2000s?
Can you objectively analyze connecting with one of your best friends over a shared obsession of this game and the hours spent combing over every secret exit together in an attempt to achieve 100% completion with giant bags of chips in hand?
Can you properly articulate the importance of a piece of art that pulled you back from the pit of despair after an unexpected tussle with death that had you feeling extestential in a way you've yet to experience before?
Is it possible or even worth your time to try and review something so pivotal to your time on this earth? I would argue no, not in the traditional sense anyway.
I can spend time telling you how this game is platforming perfection. No 2d platoformer has ever instilled in me the intense satisfaction this one does through simple and mundane actions like jumping over gaps or taking out enemies. The physicis and weight of mario are just perfect and with a boldness honed through countless trials and errors committed you will quickly find yourself gliding through levels in a way I've yet to experience in any other game. Others have been fun, fantastic and great and yet none have ever scratched the same itch this game does on a repeat playthrough.
I can tell you about the genius and charm of this game's world map. A map that is filled to the brim with secrets akin to a zelda game. One that sparks wondrous joy and excitement everytime a branching path is discovered through intuition and exploration and takes you to unexpected places and challenges. A map that was so instantly iconic that no map since has managed to touch it's glory... a magic that not even it's creators themselves have been able to replicate.
I could even talk about the introduction of Yoshi who... is just the best man. I mean seriously, a dinosaur friend you can ride? It's been 21 years since I met the guy and even now I think he is rad as hell. Not really much more to say there... yoshi is just the best.
I could talk about all of that but realistically what sets this game apart for me is that it's always been there. It was the game that made me fall in love with gaming as a whole. It opened my eyes to the wonderous worlds I could visit and the amazing adventures I would be able to take if I continued to indulge in this hobby and it is a path I haven't regretted taking since. I owe this game for the passion I have now. I owe this game for all the stories and adventures I have experienced since. I owe this game for getting me through one of the darkest parts of my life. I owe this game a 5/5 rating. It, to me, is what a true video game is meant to be. When someone says "video game" it is the first thing that pops into my mind.
At the end of the day this isn't really a review of this game. I don't really think hearing a review of it from me would mean anything since I can't even play at being objective. What this wall of text is meant to be is a love letter. It's me looking to the void that is the internet and attempting to articulate the feelings of a boy playing this game for the first time on a car ride in the Portuguese countryside.
It's not a review or my thoughts on this game... it's the reason why, to me, Super Mario World is something that transcends video games all together. It is a part of me and it always will be until the day I die... and I think that's a beautiful thing.
is it possible to put to words the feelings of a seven year old playing this game for the first time as he drove along the Portuguese countryside with his parents in the early 2000s?
Can you objectively analyze connecting with one of your best friends over a shared obsession of this game and the hours spent combing over every secret exit together in an attempt to achieve 100% completion with giant bags of chips in hand?
Can you properly articulate the importance of a piece of art that pulled you back from the pit of despair after an unexpected tussle with death that had you feeling extestential in a way you've yet to experience before?
Is it possible or even worth your time to try and review something so pivotal to your time on this earth? I would argue no, not in the traditional sense anyway.
I can spend time telling you how this game is platforming perfection. No 2d platoformer has ever instilled in me the intense satisfaction this one does through simple and mundane actions like jumping over gaps or taking out enemies. The physicis and weight of mario are just perfect and with a boldness honed through countless trials and errors committed you will quickly find yourself gliding through levels in a way I've yet to experience in any other game. Others have been fun, fantastic and great and yet none have ever scratched the same itch this game does on a repeat playthrough.
I can tell you about the genius and charm of this game's world map. A map that is filled to the brim with secrets akin to a zelda game. One that sparks wondrous joy and excitement everytime a branching path is discovered through intuition and exploration and takes you to unexpected places and challenges. A map that was so instantly iconic that no map since has managed to touch it's glory... a magic that not even it's creators themselves have been able to replicate.
I could even talk about the introduction of Yoshi who... is just the best man. I mean seriously, a dinosaur friend you can ride? It's been 21 years since I met the guy and even now I think he is rad as hell. Not really much more to say there... yoshi is just the best.
I could talk about all of that but realistically what sets this game apart for me is that it's always been there. It was the game that made me fall in love with gaming as a whole. It opened my eyes to the wonderous worlds I could visit and the amazing adventures I would be able to take if I continued to indulge in this hobby and it is a path I haven't regretted taking since. I owe this game for the passion I have now. I owe this game for all the stories and adventures I have experienced since. I owe this game for getting me through one of the darkest parts of my life. I owe this game a 5/5 rating. It, to me, is what a true video game is meant to be. When someone says "video game" it is the first thing that pops into my mind.
At the end of the day this isn't really a review of this game. I don't really think hearing a review of it from me would mean anything since I can't even play at being objective. What this wall of text is meant to be is a love letter. It's me looking to the void that is the internet and attempting to articulate the feelings of a boy playing this game for the first time on a car ride in the Portuguese countryside.
It's not a review or my thoughts on this game... it's the reason why, to me, Super Mario World is something that transcends video games all together. It is a part of me and it always will be until the day I die... and I think that's a beautiful thing.
This review contains spoilers
"It looks like things will work out here, but what about your world? Will it be alright?
"Hey other world! Be good to Josh"
I have been a massive fan of Earthbound for half of my life. I was first exposed to the game when I first played smash Bros and really liked using the characters Ness and Lucas. I had never heard of them and used my computer to look up who they were. I discovered that they were from a rpg series named Mother, a trilogy that only saw one game release in the west called Earthbound. I searched for ways to play the game and managed to get it on my dad's old laptop. It ran horribly and the games mechanics didn't really click with me and yet I saw it through to the end and fell in love with how the game ended its story. I left Earthbound with a relatively positive feeling about the game but with the opinion that it wasn't anything special. Yet, for a game that was "nothing special" it would constantly call back to me... I would play through it over and over again throughout the years as it released on different hardware and fall more and more in love with it each time. Now, as I sit here on it's 30th anniversary it stands as one of my absolute favourite games of all time, just as special to me as foundational childhood favourites like A Link to the Past, Super Mario World and Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers of sky and taking up the same space I have in my heart for games that are precious to me beyond words like Dragon Quest 5. Earthbound is special to me, it's one of my favourite things ever... but this isn't an Earthbound review... it's a Mother 3 one.
I have thought about playing Mother 3 many times throughout the years but relatively early on I clung to a stubborn belief that if I was patient enough it would be localized and I could play it for the first time in some legit capacity. This year and what has happened with Mother 3 on switch was finally the straw that broke the camel's back. I would deny myself this experience no longer, if Nintendo didn't want me to experience the game in my native language than I would finally take up the work of fans much more pationate than I and experience it that way. I bought a cheap copy of the game I found online, threw it into my gba sp and got playing.
As I crushed through each chapter I could tell I was enjoying the game but something was off. It had the same charm and heart of Earthbound but the story seemed so much more strange for lack of a better word. The whiplash between heart wrenching scenes of sadness and despair were juxtaposed with scenes of baffling humor and downright otherworldly absurdity. Earthbound had these moments of craziness that often resulted in the games best moments but the darker moments of Earthbound were so much less personal than Mother 3. Sure there are cults and alien abductions and ither zany happenings but those things were happening to the world around you. It impacts you as a member of the world rather than as a character directly, the stakes are personal to you as a resident who is destined to die unless they take up a call to action and fight. Mother 3 on the other hand is nothing but personal. The Pig army had taken over your town, corrupted your friends, ruined nature, destroyed utopia, killed your mother, taken your brother and broken your unbreakable father. You are left with nothing (well, you still got Boney so not NOTHING nothing) and it is in that moment where you set out to make things right. You've seen what's happening and even though Lucas is a cry baby they have decided enough is enough. Sure, you discover later that you are one of two beings capable of waking a sleeping dragon that has the power to re-write the world itself, but that is not what drives you initially or emotionally. Your call to action is much more personal, your reasons for saving the world are much more personal and the final climax is much more personal.
The ending is what changed my opinion of the game as a whole. Up until that point I had decided that I loved the look of the game, the rhythm based battle system coupled with Earthbound's scrolling health bar was way to much fun and that the characters were endearing and charming... but the game lacked the wow factor Earthbound did. After experiencing the ending however my opinion has completly shifted. The way in which the ending tied the whole game together for me was an absolute master class. Never before has the ending of a game altered my perception of the entire experience so much since the very first time I played Earthbound.
I included the text at the begining of this review because that moment really stuck out to me. The game's story at the end (in my interpretation anyway) was one about grief. When the worst of the worst happenes how do you respond? Do you hide yourself away, never allowing anyone to come close to you or hurt you again? Do you find the emotions to harmful to the point where you escape them through erasing everything that made you you? Do you use those emotions to spur yourself on, allowing yourself to feel it all and grow from it? I have been in a place where my heart was empty... I have tried to run to a place where no one could ever hurt me again. That attempt failed and when it did I was forced to face the feelings that drove me to emptiness. It was a turning point- would I grow and evolve or would I stay empty and die. I chose to live, I chose to grow... I chose to feel. Mother 3 presents you with these differing viewpoints and methods of dealing with grief, presents a senario where a character manages to use grief in order to grow and then in the end asks you, the player, "hey are you good?" "You've taken the time to see our story through to the end and now it's time to continue living yours... we hope you are okay!" The story of Lucas and Mother 3 is one of tragedy and loss and how one weak, timid boy was forced to grow up. From that grief he came out with strength unrivaled. It wasn't the end for him but a new begining. Armed with that knowledge the game then asks you the player "what say you?" "The world will throw everything its got at you and in those moments when you are faced with grief how will you respond?" "Please take care and grow just like Lucas!"
So yea, the ending of Mother 3 really spoke to me. I was expecting for the sad story and endearing characters to be the thing that sold me on it but was blown away when it instead offered me insight into life as a whole. It was a conclusion I had reached without ever playing the game but having it reinforced at a time in my life where I could feel myself slipping into old habits resulted in a reaffirmation of my resolve. I don't need years to know that this game is special to me... it just is already. I need more time to think it over in my brain, more time to experience it again from start to finish once more but I can say with certainty that Mother 3, like Earthbound before it, is more than just a game to me. It too takes a special place in my heart now as a game that speaks to me unlike anything that has come before it.
A truly beautiful experience that I will carry forever. The most no brainer 5/5 for me of all time.
"Hey other world! Be good to Josh"
I have been a massive fan of Earthbound for half of my life. I was first exposed to the game when I first played smash Bros and really liked using the characters Ness and Lucas. I had never heard of them and used my computer to look up who they were. I discovered that they were from a rpg series named Mother, a trilogy that only saw one game release in the west called Earthbound. I searched for ways to play the game and managed to get it on my dad's old laptop. It ran horribly and the games mechanics didn't really click with me and yet I saw it through to the end and fell in love with how the game ended its story. I left Earthbound with a relatively positive feeling about the game but with the opinion that it wasn't anything special. Yet, for a game that was "nothing special" it would constantly call back to me... I would play through it over and over again throughout the years as it released on different hardware and fall more and more in love with it each time. Now, as I sit here on it's 30th anniversary it stands as one of my absolute favourite games of all time, just as special to me as foundational childhood favourites like A Link to the Past, Super Mario World and Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers of sky and taking up the same space I have in my heart for games that are precious to me beyond words like Dragon Quest 5. Earthbound is special to me, it's one of my favourite things ever... but this isn't an Earthbound review... it's a Mother 3 one.
I have thought about playing Mother 3 many times throughout the years but relatively early on I clung to a stubborn belief that if I was patient enough it would be localized and I could play it for the first time in some legit capacity. This year and what has happened with Mother 3 on switch was finally the straw that broke the camel's back. I would deny myself this experience no longer, if Nintendo didn't want me to experience the game in my native language than I would finally take up the work of fans much more pationate than I and experience it that way. I bought a cheap copy of the game I found online, threw it into my gba sp and got playing.
As I crushed through each chapter I could tell I was enjoying the game but something was off. It had the same charm and heart of Earthbound but the story seemed so much more strange for lack of a better word. The whiplash between heart wrenching scenes of sadness and despair were juxtaposed with scenes of baffling humor and downright otherworldly absurdity. Earthbound had these moments of craziness that often resulted in the games best moments but the darker moments of Earthbound were so much less personal than Mother 3. Sure there are cults and alien abductions and ither zany happenings but those things were happening to the world around you. It impacts you as a member of the world rather than as a character directly, the stakes are personal to you as a resident who is destined to die unless they take up a call to action and fight. Mother 3 on the other hand is nothing but personal. The Pig army had taken over your town, corrupted your friends, ruined nature, destroyed utopia, killed your mother, taken your brother and broken your unbreakable father. You are left with nothing (well, you still got Boney so not NOTHING nothing) and it is in that moment where you set out to make things right. You've seen what's happening and even though Lucas is a cry baby they have decided enough is enough. Sure, you discover later that you are one of two beings capable of waking a sleeping dragon that has the power to re-write the world itself, but that is not what drives you initially or emotionally. Your call to action is much more personal, your reasons for saving the world are much more personal and the final climax is much more personal.
The ending is what changed my opinion of the game as a whole. Up until that point I had decided that I loved the look of the game, the rhythm based battle system coupled with Earthbound's scrolling health bar was way to much fun and that the characters were endearing and charming... but the game lacked the wow factor Earthbound did. After experiencing the ending however my opinion has completly shifted. The way in which the ending tied the whole game together for me was an absolute master class. Never before has the ending of a game altered my perception of the entire experience so much since the very first time I played Earthbound.
I included the text at the begining of this review because that moment really stuck out to me. The game's story at the end (in my interpretation anyway) was one about grief. When the worst of the worst happenes how do you respond? Do you hide yourself away, never allowing anyone to come close to you or hurt you again? Do you find the emotions to harmful to the point where you escape them through erasing everything that made you you? Do you use those emotions to spur yourself on, allowing yourself to feel it all and grow from it? I have been in a place where my heart was empty... I have tried to run to a place where no one could ever hurt me again. That attempt failed and when it did I was forced to face the feelings that drove me to emptiness. It was a turning point- would I grow and evolve or would I stay empty and die. I chose to live, I chose to grow... I chose to feel. Mother 3 presents you with these differing viewpoints and methods of dealing with grief, presents a senario where a character manages to use grief in order to grow and then in the end asks you, the player, "hey are you good?" "You've taken the time to see our story through to the end and now it's time to continue living yours... we hope you are okay!" The story of Lucas and Mother 3 is one of tragedy and loss and how one weak, timid boy was forced to grow up. From that grief he came out with strength unrivaled. It wasn't the end for him but a new begining. Armed with that knowledge the game then asks you the player "what say you?" "The world will throw everything its got at you and in those moments when you are faced with grief how will you respond?" "Please take care and grow just like Lucas!"
So yea, the ending of Mother 3 really spoke to me. I was expecting for the sad story and endearing characters to be the thing that sold me on it but was blown away when it instead offered me insight into life as a whole. It was a conclusion I had reached without ever playing the game but having it reinforced at a time in my life where I could feel myself slipping into old habits resulted in a reaffirmation of my resolve. I don't need years to know that this game is special to me... it just is already. I need more time to think it over in my brain, more time to experience it again from start to finish once more but I can say with certainty that Mother 3, like Earthbound before it, is more than just a game to me. It too takes a special place in my heart now as a game that speaks to me unlike anything that has come before it.
A truly beautiful experience that I will carry forever. The most no brainer 5/5 for me of all time.