I wanted to love this so much. A higher being knows I tried. There isn’t anything wrong with the story other than it being the same plot structure Rockstar has had in games for years.

Gameplay on the other hand… i thought we were passed hold left trigger and tip the right-stick towards the head. Apparently not and it’s losing atleast a star for that.

Aside from that, the game play pace was just too slow for me, trotting everywhere on a horse often felt like a chore more than a cool thing to do.

I applaud how interconnected the world is and all the secrets to discover etc, but unless you really want to spend time exploring the game it is going to feel more empty than it should. The content could of been the same, just less dispersed and it would of been great.

Losing another star for trying to make RDR2 online a thing rather than giving proper DLC.