The progenitor of moe gacha warfare (as well as Shimada Humikane), but that doesn't mean it's the holy grail.
The artwork and personality of the girls are very reflective of the historic ships; the "gameplay" is painfully dull, though. Also, doesn't help that Tanaka and company still choose to keep the game exclusive to Japan. If only KanColle Arcade was the actual game, it would at least be more graphically palatable. TL;DR: enjoy the fanart, not the game.
Overall: 4.5/10 (5)
Gameplay: 3/10
Story/Narrative: 4/10
Graphics/Visuals: 6/10
Audio/Soundtrack: 5/10
The artwork and personality of the girls are very reflective of the historic ships; the "gameplay" is painfully dull, though. Also, doesn't help that Tanaka and company still choose to keep the game exclusive to Japan. If only KanColle Arcade was the actual game, it would at least be more graphically palatable. TL;DR: enjoy the fanart, not the game.
Overall: 4.5/10 (5)
Gameplay: 3/10
Story/Narrative: 4/10
Graphics/Visuals: 6/10
Audio/Soundtrack: 5/10