this game is carried by its writing and setting, both of which are literally derivative of Sapkowski's novels. that said, as an interactive chapter of Geralt's story in a well-realized version of the northern realms, this game is phenomenal. Novigrad is one of the most fascinating places I've had the pleasure of experiencing, and feels authentic in a way I didn't think games could at the time. Geralt himself is also in peak form, and the way he responds to the world is endlessly entertaining and engaging.

the combat is a dumpster fire in a rusty dumpster. i bounced off of the Witcher 2 three separate times due to its combat, and this game is only slightly better on that front. when it works, it looks cool, but that's it. never once did i feel like i was in control of any element of a battle, since attacks are still the coding equivalent of guess-work in how they relate to animations. played as a casual narrative, this game is at its best.

also Geralt and Ciri finally get to have the depth of companionship they should have to reflect the books and it's delightful.