South Park: The Fractured But Whole is a good role-playing game! As someone that isn't a huge South Park fan I definitely thought this was a step down compared to the Stick of Truth. The combat isn't incredibly deep but it's deeper than it was in Stick of Truth. The Fractured But Whole's story is inconsistent. Similar to Stick of Truth the story in The Fractured But Whole doesn't hold any punches and doesn't care if you're offended. South Park: The Fractured But Whole according to people I trust also stays true to the TV show and that itself is praise worthy because licensed games tend to miss the mark. Despite everything I've said I still recommend this game to South Park fans! Comedy is subjective. What didn't appeal to me, might appeal to someone else.