I'd seen some call this the best game in the series and I have to disagree. While it may be more simulation-oriented than 2K22 and 2K23, it feels clunky in comparison and contains multiple annoying in-match mechanics that noticeably decreased my enjoyment of the game. Kick-outs, submissions, holds, and ladder matches are all feature mini-games that range from not fun to annoying. The game also lacks a tutorial or practice mode to help the player learn and improve.

The servers are offline now, so there are no more community creations to access, and everything must be unlocked through grinding rather than the $5 accelerator that the series usually offers.

I respect that there are some wrestling fans that still prefer 2K19, but I personally find the newer games to be a significant improvement over this style.