Last played this maybe 10 years ago on Xbox so decided to give it a fresh playthrough on PC. Very good story but there were a few times where I felt like my choices made no difference (in particular when it came to Toad at the end) and the ending felt a bit rushed. But at least the story didn't feel like it was dragging on at any point and all the characters were great.

I went for as less of an aggressive Bigby as possible (only time I really went to injure someone when given the option was Jersey Devil) and did my best to make more people like him and I think I did that and the game did a good job in giving me those options. Obviously a lot of the combat is scripted and unavoidable but I never started a fight when it gave me the option.