Yeah, someone lives under the lighthouse

In all seriously, it's really a mix bag, I like how you use the routine to make you feel safe only to slowly escalate the surrounding threats, culminating in the second view chases, that are equally creative and scary for the disorienting it's can be, especially the first and second time, but after the fourth day... it's a lot less creative, throwing all the special intrigue of the unknown for what is basically a cult and that part feels like lasted waaaay to much.
I would rather have a simple history of a man going crazy for loneliness that whatever the mothman and the cult is supposed to represent. I have other nitpicks, but in the end, just try it if you have curiosity, but be cautious