I got a bit of a hankering for some Pokémon Diamond & Pearl Versions for some reason and, on a whim, just started this up without much thought beyond “I wonder what this feels like after playing ‘Shining Pearl’.” These games are most definitely better, though, besides the original Pokémon Red & Blue Versions, these are definitely some of the most flawed the start of a new generation has been in this series. It is interesting to see how this game uses its ability to create a 3D space within this top-down angle to create more interesting areas (mainly the gyms are very interesting). These games do some interesting stuff with the Nintendo DS’ signature blend of 2D and 3D sprites, and I think these games’ overall look are probably the most interesting thing about them.

I didn’t finish this playthrough. The itch was scratched pretty fast, to be honest, and it was mainly due to the fact that I found it really hard to craft an intetesting team. We all know the memes about the classic Infernape-Staraptor-Luxray-Lucario-Garchomp-Bibarel joint, but I think those memes are the effect of one of the most boring regional Pokédexes fucking ever.

Look, I’m an advocate for smaller regional ‘dexes, I am. It’s one of my biggest complaints about newer titles that they jam pack regions with 400 Pokémon and it’s to the point where someone could have a full team of six that can cover all type advantages by the first gym. I admire this team’s attempt to stick to a nice, tight 151, but it is kind of hilarious the choices they make, especially considering all the ‘mons who got new evolutions that didn’t make the base game. Like, are we really cutting Ralts, but then leaving in Abra again? No Rhyhorn, but Geodude and Onix have just got to be there. It makes sense that you can’t have everyone there, and some of the cuts make sense if you think they crafted the regional dex around the actual region, but even then some of the choices are silly to me (and BORING!). Basically, I was having trouble using Pokémon that made me excited, and when I found out you can’t get Rotom in this game until after you get the National Dex, my interest shot through the floor, lol.

Because of that, I didn’t get much into the game’s scenario, but it still is just so crazy how much Platinum Version improves on this region. I mentioned earlier in regards to the upcoming Pokémon DLC that I miss third versions so much. It is such a cool thing they had going on to do a pair of games that introduce people to new Pokémon and new places, and then, a year or two later, refine the edges of that first pair and add a bunch more content. I remember, back during the sixth generation, I skipped ‘X & Y’ in order to wait for the next games in Kalos, since I knew the second games in each region are better, but it was to no avail, as we know. New Pokémon games still make me excited to see the direction of this series, but I don’t think we’ll ever get something like we did during the ‘00s with the third and fourth generations.

Reviewed on Jul 13, 2023


3 Comments


11 months ago

swooping in as the resident d/p defender or something, imo the dex itself is mostly fine (aside from not adding the new evolutions, probably gf's funniest ever decision), i had a lot of trouble deciding on my 6 which is always a good thing. plat expansion is great ofc but i feel like there's no shortage of cool mons in the dp dex either. that said i feel like it's not that good at actually showing off all its pokemon. i think the trainers are designed so if you fight all of them you'll have seen every pokemon in the dex, but for some reason a good majority of them feel like they only show up once, and instead every other fisherman in the game has like 8 fucking gyarados for some reason. and most of the more interesting wild encounters felt like they only show up on a couple of routes while the rest are full to the brim with your starlys and bibarels and all the most mediocre gen 1 pokemon they copy pasted everywhere for some reason. when it comes to straight teambuilding i do enjoy having to go out of my way to get everyone (i had a vespiquen!) but at the same time it doesn't really surprise me that people end up falling into using the same few.

tho it does also help that i kind of have weird backwards opinions on pokemon compared to everyone else. i don't actually like the populars like staraptor luxray garchomp very much and i'm a big sucker for those 'mid tier' weird pokemon which on second glance the dex is actually pretty full of lol, so maybe the dex just appeals to me specifically idk

11 months ago

@faea you know, i maybe should’ve clarified that i may think the dex is boring having come from recent playthroughs of FireRed and Ruby Versions, which have a lot of the same Kanto Pokémon that D/P decide to include, and since i try and use different ‘mons each playthrough, i found it hard to find picks that would excite me.

i really like your point about how the dex is spread our across trainers and routes. not having got very far into this run, that’s definitely something i didn’t get to experience. although i will say i usually have some patience with going after a ‘mon with honey but i wasn’t feeling it this time lol. maybe when i come back this i’ll use Cherubi and i’ll have some real fun >:)

11 months ago

wrt coming off fr/lg, that might be a part of it but i do think they also just picked some of the least remarkable gen 1 pokemon to plaster everywhere. like gyarados is cool but the lustre is gone a bit once you've seen like six hundred of them in the past three trainer battles. past that like, geodude? zubat? machoke? idk ponyta is alright? like i love a lot of kanto pokemon but the ones they put front and centre in sinnoh are some of the most boring ones to begin with imo lol. past that though I think it is also just a slow start when it comes to new or interesting mons (replying with the speed of blissey's hp bar sorry)