This is the best game I have ever played. Everything about it just works for me. The story is amazing, emotional, and resonating. The characters are complex and believable. The world is gorgeous, and an absolute joy to just explore. Even the more debated aspects just speak to me. The movement and deliberate feel to everything makes it the most immersive non-VR game i have ever played, and it even competes with VR's offerings. The gunplay is simple but still captures that old western feel.
I love love love this game.