I blew through this one in one sitting. This is much more of what I was hoping for from the first DLC. It even surpasses the base game in a lot of ways. Fully utilizes the dream logic of the "dark place" to put the player in novel combat and exploration scenarios that are disorienting and visually striking. The giant rusty compartmentalized wheel that you run through is the closest this first game comes to nailing the Silent Hill vibe, but the real highlight is that last run to the lighthouse with the extreme light/dark contrast. Breaking down the cover and luring the enemies into the open areas, hoping the spotlight swings back around in time to kill them before they can kill you, is a really satisfying little gameplay loop. This also does a good job bookending the story, taking you back to Alan's original dream from the beginning of the base game.

You can see Remedy leaning into the dream logic that would come to define their next big Wake-verse game Control. It might be a little while before I get to Alan Wake 2, but I hope it's more along these lines.