Kind of a controversial opinion but I loved Yui's route. Not saying it was some Koe no Katachi tier (not even close) but as an H-game that was released in the 2000s, I like it and made Yui redeemable to me even though being a horrible person.

Was not a fan of returning characters another stories (except Hayami). Would have given it 4 stars if it had a better Hamaji route that also includes Yaoi romance. Fuck Maki's route btw! Never liked her and she doesn't deserve Hamaji.