I dunno. I definitely see why other people like it but the lack of flicking and tapping makes it way more difficult for me personally. My thumb will literally snap into a 90 degree angle before it presses the A button. Or sometimes it locks up and I can't press in time. The "Tap Mode" (I think it's called that?) feels kind of like a consolation prize, it's absolutely what it says it is and there's no flicking. The QoL features like being able to see how good your timing actually was on the bottom screen & the practice modes supporting the player a little better (like showing you the beat if you mess up too many times in a row) are great though, I don't mind those.

I didn't really have fun with it and find it less accessible because of my hypermobility, but all that being said I'm sure literally anyone else could and I can't find it in me to straight up diss a Rhythm Heaven game. Maybe it wouldn't have thrown me off this badly had I played the Wii game before this one so I could see what direction the series was going in.

TL;DR: I hate having disordered fine motor skills