i played this game on my brother's xbox when i was like 11. my fond memories of it are mostly out of nostalgia but i do still think it holds up really well. the soundtrack and visuals are seriously beautiful and the atmosphere is so gorgeous. my main nitpick is that the controls really made me mad sometimes. there was also almost this lack of depth in some scenes and i found myself accidentally falling off of staircases and beams because of it. i saw a lot of complaints about how the story was confusing or lacked clarity but it's not a big deal to me because it was clearly intentional and this is one of few cases where i'm alright with that.