PEAK but would be better with less cooking scenes also I love kirei kotomine so much

Genuinely one of the greatest works of fiction I've ever read, despite some of is flaws it has.
Definitely Nasu's Magnum Opus
Played it on PC with fan patches, saying this since there is no PC option to choose here.

this is such a complete package of a story, the characters genuinely great all around some of my favorite in recent memory

Nasu is a mixed bag of a writer. He can make excellent characters, a varied and interesting world, and a pretty good story. However the constant 30 minute exposition dumps and cheesy ass Servants explaining their powers mid battle hurts it a lot. The first half of Fate route is some of the worst pacing I've ever seen, and yet I somehow ended up liking it more than UBW. If you can get past its flaws, it's an excellent story with compelling characters. Sakura and Shirou were my faves.