I feel like that talking fully about Everhood with the respet it deserves its almost impossible, but I'll try anyway. Some people would call it pretencious, but that would implie that the game pretends to be more than it really is, and Everhood has a lot of interesting things to say. It feels proud to be a videogame, with all that carries: being a happy experience and a sad one, funny and scary, relaxed and challenging... And it tackles the theme of death and how it gives meaning to life, albeit being a pretty common theme in certain movies and books, unlike any other game I've seen.
Does anything I'm saying make sense? I don't know, nor I care, but please, play Everhood, even if you don't end up seing its themes and story the same way I do, it's still a fun an unique experience, on that should be at least tried by everyone.
Also the gameplay it's incredibly fun, challenging and the music is out of this world, I almost forgot to say that