The first and in my opinion the best. This game is something special that I feel can't be replicated, it's early 2010's shovelware basically, but that was part of the charm. This truly is the goat.

The most fun spin-off in my opinion, has a lot of content, lot of new fun parody ideas, fun characters and missions. This is a great spin on the original Goat Simulator.

A fun new return to form, but the missions here aren't always as fun as the original. It has a pretty fun world to explore and a couple new fun features but yeah.

A fun enough game where you do everything except rob the bank you're supposed to. It has a decent world and a lot of new things to do but it's just not as fun as the next three.

A decent game, has a lot of content but a lot of it is kinda mediocre. It has some fun things to do, fun missions and some other aspects but ultimately the others are better.

Easily the worst Goat Simulator in my opinion, it has the least fun world to explore, the least fun gameplay mechanics and just an overall worse experience compared to the others.