I love this game, but I hate John Marston. He is a sissy do-gooder who feels completely out of place in the time and place he's in. Fool like that would not have survived wery long in the enviroment. They wrote him to reflect what they would assume typical gamer to feel, and that's why he has to be utterly discusted while skinning an animal, something he does every day. He's just a millennial gamer boy, lost in a wrong place at the wrong time.