This game was amazing, I can't believe I put it down 9 years ago and never finished it. I'm simply giving it a 4 based on my experience but I could definitely see this being a higher rating for others. Supergiant Games is always great at not only nailing gameplay but immersion and providing top tier audio tracks to go along with it.
My only knock was that the combat was a little strange for me when I first started playing it and when I came back to it the mechanics were hard to get a handle on. Mileage may vary on that part.

Maybe one day I'll play through it again start to finish without a 9 year gap to experience it as intended but I still had a very positive experience.