Surely one of the best games I've played. However, I'm still somewhat reticent to call it a masterpiece. Everyone speaks of how great of a game Elden Ring is, so I'll talk about what I found to be somewhat disappointing.
Many boss fights didn't feel as good as Sekiro or Dark Souls 3. Some weapons are unbalanced, just like some enemies, bosses and builds. Some weapons scale very poorly. The reused assets are sometimes very apparent. Optional dungeons tend to have repetitive boss fights.