Overall the game is amazing but I think the story could be a tiny bit better

Everyone justifies the story being eh because RDR2 makes up for the plot holes and makes you feel for certain characters - which is fine - but RDR2 was not a thing when this game released so it's not a valid excuse

I think the story needed a bit more padding and if it were to release now, with the way rockstar has been with storytelling, this would've banged 10x harder for sure