Platforming, controls, and camera were all so bad it makes this game really frustrating to play. I'd rather watch a walkthrough

Some of the puzzles are a but too frustrating and the combat is a bit too repetitive, but this game is excellent! As someone who played it for the first time in 2023, it is well worth your time still!

It also might have the best sound design I've ever experienced in a game.

This game makes worse every gameplay aspect that made the first game enjoyable. The ending is SUPER anticlimactic. It's just not worth your time. But the first game is.

I think I spent more time waiting for my A.I. teammates to catch up than I did shooting bad guys.

There's a lot to like here, but also a lot to scoff at.

The environment and gameplay are really cool, but definitely feels like a game from 2009 because car handling and aiming suck. Not enough for me to drop the game though.

The story is bland and predictable, as are the characters. I would love a remake with a better story/characters and more fluid gameplay.

Totally fine in every way. It's just the same thing. If this is your first game in the franchise, you'll love it, but I've played this same game 3 times before this one. They should take the numbers out of the title so maybe more people will play it without thinking they're missing a bunch of backstory.

I'm glad it was on gamepass. I'll probably pick it up when it's on sale for under $10, because it's still fun.

Mediocre story. Bad voice acting for DC characters. Unbalanced players. All makes for a pretty lackluster experience to a really cool concept.

2009

I really like this game. it shouldn't work but absolutely does. Finds an interesting way to tie into the narrative and knows what it is. The fighting mechanics suck, but the puzzling nature really works for me. It's like the early Resident Evil entries, but fewer enemies and the inclusion of moral dilemmas.

It's not perfect, but is way better than it has any right to be.

The original game was bad and this is somehow worse. I'm so uninterested in this game after 30 minutes that I'm gonna abandon it. It's not worth my time.

It's got a lot of issues. A lot you would expect, but way more than I thought possible. Like, how do you make the Court of Owls boring?!

Slight improvement, but it's still just open door, punch bad guy, open door, punch bad guy, open door, ....

"Button Mashing: The Game 2" is pretty good!

Solid entry in the movie tie-in genre. Wasn't expecting survival horror, but so glad I got it! Would love a modern-made open world Skull Island game!

Really interesting world
Pretty high learning curve, but it's kind of refreshing as opposed to super easy Telltale Games.
I pulled up a walkthrough guide about halfway through and had more fun experiencing everything without getting frustrated at a puzzle.

Smoother gameplay than the original, but not quite as good a story. Still an excellent game I'm glad I'm finally getting around to.