Just finished Red Dead Redemption 2, and it was exceptional. Despite initial uncertainties, Arthur's well-written character, memorable moments, engaging gameplay, and immersive elements made it a thoroughly enjoyable journey. In short, a great experience. I really enjoyed the gunplay. The guns feel like they have weight to them and entering slow-mo doing cool stuff is always fun.
The best aspect of this game is how the world is reactive and even the choices you have kinda matter. Random encounters feel organic too.