It's very rough around the edges but I can't help but enjoy it. Despite all the stupid facial animations, awkward and sometimes random evidence needed to progress, the weird ending. The experience overall was really special and cohesive.

Phelps is a great but flawed protagonist, which I prefer as it gives the character a form of complexity. And you're not always sure what to think of him. All of your partners are likable (except Roy) and each case has tons of memorable characters. There were a lot of just complicated and thought provoking moments where I was just sitting there trying to find the right evidence I needed and I felt really in the moment trying to figure out the mystery. There's lots of intense moments and really awesome vocal performances from everyone.

Some gripes. The open world is not great and does not really add much to the game. The collectibles SUCK. Why even put them in if you can't do anything with them? Collecting the cars is fine. But why the film reels? Just don't bother by that point.

The switch port is ok, but it can be choppy with some bugs. In general the gameplay is simple: gunplay is nothing crazy with basic shooting and cover systems. A lot of the chases have awful rubber banding once you notice it. It is impossible not to once you see it.

Still, a very unique title from Rockstar that could have been expanded on more. But I think it's still a great time on its own.