Well…
Carl: It is the route that I liked the least, it is very stressful and I can understand that that is the intention but the ending is not satisfactory, you can tell that it was the first route they did, making it look low quality at times.

Jenna: I enjoyed this one more and in this route we do sympathize more with Jenna and understand her points of view, what I didn't like was that it won't contribute anything new and will try to conclude many loose ends feeling rushed, it is entertaining but not as shocking as the others.

tj: poor him, the people who first chose the cat did not expect it, here he theorized that Chase's true personality is shown here and what he is capable of committing the same atrocious acts (if we assume that it was he who killed to Sydney).

flynn: this route is crazy, compared to jenna's route here there are too many themes but it is well balanced so that the ending leaves you in shock, in the epilogue seeing Chase at the most depressing point of all the routes is very melancholic and poetic, an otter without soul and identity.

Leo: this is my favorite, it is the first one I chose when I played it and the one that impacted me personally, this game caught me by surprise making the same mistake in Leo's bad ending, accepting that we will not be able to help a loved one with our love and having to abandon it so it doesn't do more damage, it hurts.

Yeah a lot of text...