an enigma of a game. with most video games that put me off, i'm able to, in some capacity, contort myself into going "well here was the intention and here was the demographic". i truly cannot do that with this game, because who on earth at square enix played dark souls and went "we should add a terrible loot system and necessitate grinding"? it's a damn shame too, because this game has such great catharsis when it works. jack's violent animations just feel good to get, the level design is usually pretty engaging, and boss fights have a nice spectacle to them that fit in with the final fantasy aesthetic while still creating this new, obscene and violent performance.

but i cannot stress enough how shitty the game gets by endgame when it turns out that you basically have to grind your eyeballs out just to get armor that will stop you from dying in two hits, or get equipment with job affinities you want. it's shitty! it sucks! why did they add this! it's another example of square enix getting in their own way with a genuinely great game concept. you could argue that this was always in team ninja's design doc, but i heavily doubt it and more expect the shitty aspects of this game were direct demands from square as a publisher. regardless of how it happened, it just sucks outrageously that this got bogged down with mechanics that actively made the experience worse and turned this unexpected hit into a turbo-mid product.

Reviewed on Feb 21, 2024


5 Comments


2 months ago

will stress this is not at all a grind-heavy game until the dlc. the endgame is just hard. every mission has the same "fight a few enemies to get equipment the level as the mission" formula and the endgame isn't really any different in that sense. played on hard without party and didn't have to grind at any point

now - the dlc - that's another story

2 months ago

@chandler oh i mean, i didn't "have" to grind at any point, but it certainly felt like the game wanted me to because by the end i was regularly 20 average equipment levels below what the mission level was, and it made my experience observably worse. i beat the game on hard and felt burnt out by the end because it seemed pretty obvious that i could learn a boss' patterns and spend 3x as long in the fight compared to a fight where i had grinded for better equipment for like 2 hours. that's my big problem w/the game.

2 months ago

Chiming in to say that the equipment problem is absolutely on Team Ninja and is relevant to basically all of their modern releases. Blaming it on Square seems really random, especially when the system may as well be copy-pasted from Nioh 2.

2 months ago

@AiriBan i've yet to play or see a team ninja game that had this type of system in it, meanwhile square has had useless loot systems like this in a lot of their recent games. it's just speculation on my part at the end of the day.

2 months ago

That's why I said modern team ninja game, all of them have the same shitty loot system and it sucks. Just look at the top review for Nioh 2 and you'll get the picture lmao.