I didn't like it that much at first. I didn't like some of the choices they made with the Penguin or Thomas Wayne.
After reading White Knight and some other non canon I gave it another chance.
It was better than I thought.
I'm debating playing the sequel.

I liked the second one for the same reasons as the first.

The puzzles had balanced difficulty. They seemed fair to me. They were designed to be funny as if figuring one out was how the punchline was delivered.