I suck and don't play it too much to talk about the multiplayer aspects, but the story mode is fun and the table turf minigames are great. If only it had the rhythm mini games back. Then it'd be 5/5. The thing that pulls it through is the alterna logs and the sunken scrolls, other than the story mode could've been better.
At least I can say that a bear sucked an old man dry and be completely serious about it.