simplecoffee
2018
This is the only Mario Party that will let me main Bowser, so obviously it's the best one. I also prefer it to Superstars in terms of gameplay (with the caveat, of course, that I'm not a big console gamer in general, having grown up on MS-DOS and emulation, and struggle with the z-axis at the best of times). Using one Joy-Con is great and the vibration/tilt-control games are stupid fun. A thorough joy. And also - it bears repeating - I can main Bowser. What's not to love?
1992
Played on MS-DOS in the 90s and early 00s. Changed my brain chemistry in a fundamental way. The sound design, level design and sprite design are all a pure delight. Replayed via DOS emulator in late 2013; completed the full game during that playthrough. Have since logged multiple hours on the HD Steam rerelease.
This compilation was my first experience of all these Mario games.
SMB1: delightful remaster, fixed a lot of the janky controls of the original, BUT it fucked up the underground theme by adding a backbeat.
SMB2: game of the year every year. First Mario game I remember beating - first with save states, then without. The remastered artwork is absolutely gorgeous, especially in World 4. This is my go-to game when I want to do some Stress Platforming™.
SMB3: absolutely fantastic in every way. I may have beaten this a few years before beating SMB2, but I only have vague memories of the later stages and Bowser fight so I can't say that for certain. I especially love the mazes. It took me until 2022 (when I finally beat SMB1 for the first time) to realize the mazes are a time-honoured Mario tradition.
SMW: fun and bright and always rewarding. Beat this for the first time in 2013, using a guide for some of the harder-to-find secrets.
Lost Levels: couldn't have beaten this without save states in a hundred years. MUCH easier as Luigi. Chad behaviour from Luigi to be honest
SMB1: delightful remaster, fixed a lot of the janky controls of the original, BUT it fucked up the underground theme by adding a backbeat.
SMB2: game of the year every year. First Mario game I remember beating - first with save states, then without. The remastered artwork is absolutely gorgeous, especially in World 4. This is my go-to game when I want to do some Stress Platforming™.
SMB3: absolutely fantastic in every way. I may have beaten this a few years before beating SMB2, but I only have vague memories of the later stages and Bowser fight so I can't say that for certain. I especially love the mazes. It took me until 2022 (when I finally beat SMB1 for the first time) to realize the mazes are a time-honoured Mario tradition.
SMW: fun and bright and always rewarding. Beat this for the first time in 2013, using a guide for some of the harder-to-find secrets.
Lost Levels: couldn't have beaten this without save states in a hundred years. MUCH easier as Luigi. Chad behaviour from Luigi to be honest
2000
1990