Ultimately an interesting title that has the levels from THPS 2 and THPS 1 but with 3 levels that treyarch created. The physics feel very different from other THPS games made by neversoft but not nearly as bad as some other titles in the series(THPS HD comes to mind) The levels from 2 and 1 are carbon copies even down to the goals, which is a bit awkward in the THPS1 levels when the score goals can be done in 1 jump because of the increased amount of points you get.
The levels made by treyarch are awful, probably the worst level design in the Tony Hawk series, except for the tampa competition level which made its way to Tony Hawk's Underground. There are no good lines in either club london or construction site to get the points required, and each of the goals is not set up the way a neversoft title would be.

Still a fun game that I might replay, and Im sure it was cool at the time to have a title on the OG XBOX, but certainly not like the masterpieces of THPS1-4.

Prior to the release of Pro Skater 1+2 (and even after the release of Pro Skater HD), this was the definitive remaster of the first two Pro Skater games. And even then calling it a remaster for both games might be stretching it, since it's mostly a remaster of Pro Skater 2.

Despite the fact that Pro Skater 3 was already out by this time, Activision wanted a launch title for the OG Xbox. And since Pro Skater 3 wouldn't be out until a few months later, Activision decided to task Treyarch a remaster of Pro Skater 2. It probably could have been a disaster, but surprisingly it worked.

2X is a really good game for what it is, but also has some of the same issues as the original Pro Skater 2 (i.e. Big Drop feature). It's interesting to go back to this game now, and it wouldn't hurt to play this one, even after playing Pro Skater 1+2.

I can't really give the twenty year-olds too much shit for salivating over spot-the-difference remakes of games that came out on PS3. This was my one. A US-only, Xbox-only expanded remake of Tony Hawk's 2 with all the THPS1 levels and five new exclusive levels too. There couldn't have been a more tantalising carrot to dangle in front of my 13 year-old face. planettonyhawk.gamespy.com became a daily visit, and I'd constantly revisit my folder of THPS2X screenshots once my hour of 56k internet access was up.

It's only after experiencing the clean Dreamcast version, PC version with all the THPS1 levels patched in, 2012 remake, THUGPRO and 2020 remake, that emulation had caught up to the point where I could finally realise the dream.

It's Tony Hawk's 2. Cleaner than the old PlayStation version, sure. I couldn't say for certain that it looks any better than the Dreamcast or PC versions without doing a direct side-by-side comparison. I remember marveling at the lighting in promotional screenshots back in the day, so maybe there's something there, but it's just as likely that they were nonsense.

The original levels are abysmal, by the way. They'd be subpar for Evolution Skateboarding. THPS5's levels soar above this scattered, linear dogshit. The one skatepark level is okay, but really just an early iteration of THUG's Tampa skatepark with less flow to it. Don't play this for the new levels.

Otherwise, you've got a fine way to play THPS1&2, with all the old THPS2 stuff. Folk coming off the new remake will be alarmed at how juddery and limited the original games are. Technical combos rarely gain points as quickly as just doing big jumps and spinning, and there's the infamous "BIG DROP" thing that makes you wipe out if you drop from too tall a height. It doesn't emulate nearly as well as the PlayStation or Dreamcast games either, so it's unlikely to become the most practical option.

THPS2 is a beloved game though, and this is the most "deluxe" version of the original. It's just as it used to be, with the full soundtrack (not THPS1's though), extras and unlockable Spider-Man. There's a satisfaction in mastering the quirks of the old physics and a comfort in the atmosphere that subsequent remakes haven't quite captured. This is the old THPS2 you used to play with RF cables on your mate's bedroom television. I just thought that fans ought to know they really don't have to seek this one out. Just play the version you have.

Probably the best version of THPS2. It has the first Pro Skater levels unlocked after you finish the main campaign. However, you'll breeze right through those bonus levels due to the high score goals unchanged from the original game. Manual filled combos which weren't present in PS1 will make short work of those goals.

The big drop penalty from PS2 is still present while playing the PS1 levels. Levels like Downhill Jam will be troublesome to play through because they are very height intensive and you'll bail no matter how high your landing stat is.

It also doesn't contain the soundtrack from PS1, but the Xbox had the feature to play music from ripped CDs, so you could theoretically create a PS1+PS2 soundtrack through those means.

I played this version over the vanilla THPS2 because I figured this would have the best engine and most content, and I was indeed right. This game not only includes the entirety of THPS2 in the THPS3 engine but also includes all the maps from THPS1 as well to just make this game have a ton of content and things to do. There are even unique bonus stages that are cool. This game introduces manuals to the gameplay formula, and they do so much to make the game more freeform that it basically makes it impossible to go back to the first game. You can now continue your combos literally anywhere as long as there is a short enough distance between your next rail/ramp to keep your manual going for. The new levels are also pretty well designed though I do think some of them are a bit too big and prefer the THPS1 levels overall. The soundtrack is also a step down from game 1 imo. Despite those minor setbacks the gameplay improvements are so vast that this game is still absolutely worth playing and better than the first game.

I was within the age bracket where my Tony Hawk experience began with the Underground games.

I chose 2x because after booting up the OG THPS, I decided that I could handle no walking, but I absolutely could not handle no manuals. Maybe I'll come back to it some day.

From my understanding, the THPS2 portion of this "collection" is unchanged from the original, outside of visuals.

I'm not a huge fan of the THPS2 levels, honestly. Really love the THPS1 ones, but they suffer from the Big Drop mechanic.

This is definitely worth playing if you're looking to experience THPS1 and 2 in a slightly more updated form.

If a video game could function as a time capsule, the first two Tony Hawk Pro Skater games are DEFINITELY that. I grew up playing this game religiously -amongst other Pro Skater titles- and after two decades later it was a wonderfully nice trip down memory lane.

For two decades the game hasn't aged as poorly as one would think. Aside from the graphics that look horrible even for low poly standards, the gameplay is still enjoyable even to this day. I found myself refusing to let the controller down till I 100% each level and gold medaled every championship. Almost like the game is enticing me to keep trying and holding the reward in front of me barely at arms distance where I know I can complete the level if I just keep trying and stay focus!

The maps in the first two games are also probably the most iconic compared to other games after 1 and 2. Subjective, I'll admit, but I'm sure most will admit there is a sliver of truth to that claim as well. I love that even after two decades later I still remember all the secrets and easter eggs I'd find throughout the levels, although I'm sure I also remember them because I used to inspect ALL the areas when I was younger lmfao. It's a trip playing this game after playing the remake of the first two Pro Skater games last year. Everything still feels 1:1

Unfortunately, the music in this game is admittedly repetitive despite it still having some iconic tracks. 15 songs is just not enough to keep the game feeling fresh while constantly retrying the levels after crossing off an objective or needing to restart a run. It's not that big of a problem in today's age though thanks to media streaming sites and apps, but still something that can't be overlooked.

Overall, it's been such a pleasant experience being able to revisit this game again with a new lens and better coordinated hands than my kid version self could ever. 100% all maps myself without the help of my siblings was probably the best feeling I've gotten out of this game for sure.