Look, Madden NFL 12 was a decent attempt for its time. The new physics engine and collision stuff was cool, seeing some old-school legends was fun, and the Franchise mode had neat additions. But man, those bugs were atrocious, the commentary was even worse than usual, and the overall AI felt just...dumb. If you're desperate for a classic Madden fix on older consoles, it might be tolerable, but don't expect a revolutionary football experience.