This game was a slight improvement over years 1-4 but unfortunately not enough to pull it out of the average rank. The added dueling into the gameplay which, while better than the original, still becomes stale fairly quickly. The move set is still not differentiated enough to make it worth playing with multiple different characters making the characters once again just feel like skin swaps. While the overall experience was slightly better the story somehow became even worse. There were multiple times me and my wife said if we didn’t know the Harry Potter story we would have no clue as to what was going on.

Just like years 1-4 I had an ok time playing this but if I wasn’t playing with my wife and we didn’t love Harry Potter I’m not sure how much I would have enjoyed this game. Even as a big Harry Potter fan I just cannot give this game any higher than an average score. If you are into Harry Potter you’ll at least have a decent time but if you don’t know anything about Harry Potter sit back and read the books or watch the movies before playing this otherwise I can’t see where there would be much enjoyment.

.

Reviewed on Feb 09, 2023


4 Comments


It wasn't this game but there was one game during this period where I looked at footage and even did a demo play on and went "wow these Modern LEGO games sure didn't try to expand on the gameplay after the Sixth Gen ended huh?"

Also, and I for sure know LHP didn't have this, but I'm more into the voiceless slapstick than the full voice humor. I just find that funnier!
"Didn't have this" as in having voices, I'm like 100% sure this was before Lego Batman 2 and had the mumbles cause of it

1 year ago

I haven’t played any Lego games with full on voice acting. I do enjoy the slapstick mumbles as well and imagine that voice acting takes some of the charm out of it.

1 year ago

I've gotten to the voice acting, and they still had funny physical jokes they did with the movie lines in Lord of the Rings, but the problem i've gotten too since voice acting is the games get too big for me. Up to this game is fun to 100% for me (disregarding Lego Star Wars 3/Pirates of the Caribbean), but Lego Batman 2 and LOTR was getting to be too much. still need to see continue my trek through the series though.