This game was woeful. Corny story, terrible voice acting, none of the interesting weapons from the first game, and the enemies were literal sprites. Worst thing to happen in 2003 by far.
There's a small sliver of time where shooters did something transcendental. From Aliens Versus Predator 2, to the mainline 007 entries. There's a magic to them that is hard to capture, and this was one of the best.
Great roster of characters, iconic announcer, but ultimately a repetitive and bland gameplay loop. I may just be salty because Quake was no longer a single-player focused game.