This game SLAPS! So glad I grabbed it to replay. Wish it would get a remaster or backwards compatible port.

Fun original ideas, solid gameplay, breezy story, and genuine intrigue throughout.

It's got a lot of issues. A lot you would expect, but way more than I thought possible. Like, how do you make the Court of Owls boring?!

The original game was bad and this is somehow worse. I'm so uninterested in this game after 30 minutes that I'm gonna abandon it. It's not worth my time.

It's just a bad game. Lots of controls are touchy. None of the mechanics are particularly good. The jokes definitely don't hold up well, especially in Peter's levels. The jokes are one-note and tiresome. There's absolutely no reason to seek this out, even for nostalgia's sake.

This game is the GOAT sports game.

This game makes worse every gameplay aspect that made the first game enjoyable. The ending is SUPER anticlimactic. It's just not worth your time. But the first game is.

I really like this game. it shouldn't work but absolutely does. Finds an interesting way to tie into the narrative and knows what it is. The fighting mechanics suck, but the puzzling nature really works for me. It's like the early Resident Evil entries, but fewer enemies and the inclusion of moral dilemmas.

It's not perfect, but is way better than it has any right to be.

Love the concept. Remember it since announced, but stayed away because of bad reviews. Figured it cant be that bad, right? It's not awful, it's just boring, uninspired, and has clunky handling. Not worth the 4 hrs it took to beat.

Mediocre story. Bad voice acting for DC characters. Unbalanced players. All makes for a pretty lackluster experience to a really cool concept.

The fact that this even kind of works is a miracle.

Hit me right in the nostalgia.

This game is way better than it has any right to be.

I desperately want to play an updated version of this game!

It is what it is, but it sure is fun!

GOATed