First of all, the saving system was... horrible.

I loved exploring the world in the beginning from a FP perspective. Really enjoyable. I wasn't expecting anything too dense or thorough. The pieces of eight thing was annoying but it's okay. The problem comes when you have to walk through the forest, specially in Monkey Island. With this game mode it got really boring and even confusing. The third chapter was the most disappointing. You are the one who does the thougher job, who fights LeChuck; you finally get to be with Kate, Elaine and Guybrush on a ship and later in Melee Island and... it seems like they barely notice you. It feels like you are a viewer again.

I like new approaches to an universe like Monkey Island's. This one just didn't fully work.