I have a very complicated relationship with this game. When it came out, I hated it. I hated most of the new Pokemon, I hated Mt. Coronet, and I hated Team Galactic. I had started high school at this point, and felt like it was time to move on from Pokemon. I decided to complete the National Dex and walk away.
I spent every bus ride to and from school grinding out levels to evolve my Pokemon and fill that dex. I got most of the way there, but before I finished Soul Silver and the competitive scene renewed my interest in the series and I decided to stick around. Diamond and Pearl represent the lowest level of interest in Pokemon I've ever had.
Despite that bias, Diamond and Pearl are fine. They're still good Pokemon games. It's not getting more than a 4 though because Lickilicky is a war crime and I will never forgive.
I spent every bus ride to and from school grinding out levels to evolve my Pokemon and fill that dex. I got most of the way there, but before I finished Soul Silver and the competitive scene renewed my interest in the series and I decided to stick around. Diamond and Pearl represent the lowest level of interest in Pokemon I've ever had.
Despite that bias, Diamond and Pearl are fine. They're still good Pokemon games. It's not getting more than a 4 though because Lickilicky is a war crime and I will never forgive.
If it wasn't for the inclusion of WiFi battling & trading (which doesn't work anymore) this game would've been a mediocre sequel. Many of the new monsters I personally found underwhelming in terms of design, this was the first time a game didn't motivate me to catch a full team. The battle gameplay is slower than its ever been and I found much of the map forgettable. I've heard Platinum was better but this didn't leave me wanting more of Sinnoh. Once again features locked events only accessible via hacking.
An milestone for Pokemon. The 4th generation games as a whole represent a peak in overall game quality for me. Even though this game doesn't hold up well, it's an important first first step in Pokemon's glory days, and introduced a lot of mainstays to the series, online play, the physical/special split, the day/night cycle, etc. While this game is now outclassed by Platinum in every way, it's still worth recognizing for everything it has done for the series.
As per usual, Pokémon charms players with its addictive monster-catching/training elements, but bores them with its repetitive, tedious combat system, now aggravated by excruciatingly slow battles. Although the new setting is wonderfully rich with lore, the plot is too reminiscent of the previous generation’s with shallow characters and writing. Level design provides enough room for exploration to make the journey fairly enjoyable along with some pleasant optional side-quests and additional activities.
Hardly played enough of it in my youth (again, turn-based RPGs do little for me), but I do remember it being a fun time. From watching my brother play this (and just from being a kid), I have a huge attachment to the Gen 4 era of Pokémon, so I still get a bit of a nostalgic thrill when I see Diamond/Pearl.