Reviews from

in the past


fucking hate this shit. garbage payoff to a mystery that could've been interesting

That time Keiichi spoke facts for about 20 hours.

Love it~

This review contains spoilers

everything was great until the takano reveal

HANYUUUUUUUUUUUU

A forma como a historia foi se conectando e respondendo ~quaseeeeeeee~ tudo foi PEAK FICTION

AU AU ENDING

todo mundo virou au au


gave up on the VN and decided to read the manga instead but great chapter nonethless

This review contains spoilers

hanyuu? more like hanyuuseless y'know what im saying

This review contains spoilers

if tatarigoroshi is so good then where's tatarigoroshi 2

Ryukishi was rightfully very anxious about releasing the chapter,and yet Minagoroshi ends up being the perfect vessel to answer most of the mysteries set by the story over the years.
Full of hope and perseverance,this may be the chapter with the biggest heart of them all,even in the face of the insurmountable odds our main characters are faced with.
There's definitely something to be said about the middle of the story slowing down perhaps a bit too much,or the new character,Hanyuu,having powers a bit too undefined for a murder mystery,but these are nitpicks in the face of another banger from Ryukishi.
Yeah,Hanyuu did nothing wrong,she's a great addition to the cast,flaws and all!

I dedicate this tale to my beloved blue haired loli, Rika Furude

Simultaneously one of my favourite and least favourite arcs

During Tatarigoroshi: Keiichi may be the greatest character of all time

During this chapter: Holy shit he really is

And the last scene is the most powerful and memorable antagonist's speech in all fiction

I don't know if this works for or against the game, but I read the first chapter, took a break, then read the rest of the game in one continuous 9 and a half hour session. I suppose it's nice that it could pull me in like that, considering most of the plot points are built around resolving hanging plot threads rather than holding much intrigue into itself. Minagoroshi feels like a very transitional chapter to me (as did Tsumihoroboshi, but it felt much more "contained" to me as well) and I'm sure that my opinion of this will change wildly depending on how Matsuribayashi gets along with it.

absolute kino (takano could step on me)

I really liked the ending. I honestly can't find myself to hate all of the higurashi chapters due to my mindset not criticizing them as one individual thing that stands out of the rest, but how they help connect with each other. I really liked how it turned out with setting up hanyuu, expanding rika's character more, and introducing the main villain.

This review contains spoilers

the most sociopolitically astute chapter so far, on both a more abstract philosophical level and a practical one: ryukishi is fundamentally a behaviorist, ethically and psychologically, and remains committed to absolute understanding, empathy, and trust rather than the simple pleasures of condemnation and the attendant voyeurism (with the exception of the overarching antagonist who is, as of this chapter's ending, a scenery chewing freak in a rly fun wild way). the hanyuu stuff is great and very moving, echoes of codependency with two characters trapped in perpetual pre-adolescence, one's loneliness making her determined to change and do nothing and the other's driving her to desperate attempts to escape the stultifying world of repetition and isolation. so much rage at the way liberal-democratic systems fail vulnerable people and hide behind the cheap excuse of bureaucratic process, while it complexifies the understanding of collective direct action and political resistance which was explored in previous chapters, reinforcing the duality of who "counts" as a comrade and how the, to some degree, fundamentally conservative nature of hinamizawa's political organizing can be modulated and overcome. plus the climax just goes apeshit. what the fuck even

Everything in this series was caused by either an extremely horny woman or an extremely dead child.

Minagoroshi is a great chapter. It ties all the questions solved nicely, and solves the mystery of hinamizawa greatly. Although, i find ch3 better only because how hopeless it makes you feel. ch7 had a very slow start, and it really did not make me feel sad or hopeless in the moments where it was meant to. loved the ending though

overall, minagoroshi is a great chapter. sure, it has some flaws but it does its job as a answer arc well. 4/5, 8.5/10

takano maniacal laughter 5 stars

This review contains spoilers

:0

This review contains spoilers

As expected of the master Ryukishi, Chapter 7 is as amazing as the rest. Rika's perspective is very interesting and while Hanyuu does tick me off, I acknowledge that she has an important role in the story. The intense emotional payoffs are rampant in this chapter with Satoko finally standing up to Teppei and the spiraling disaster at the end. Chapter 7 manages to tell a story that's both extremely hopeful and heavy at the same time and it felt good to ride the emotional rollercoaster. I am a bit sad that the mystery is all but gone now but the story continues to be enthralling nonetheless.

can someone change the icons for these games please they look really fucking ugly in my profile and i don't want my stranger internet friends to think i'm a weeb

The existence of Hanyuu is just wrong in all the senses wtf ryukishi was thinking

That aside, Satoko and Rika (even Keiichi) deserved all the spotlights they got, they really saved this episode


This review contains spoilers

A very enjoyable chapter. Great character POVs and answers a lot of mysteries. My only issue with it is that the whole "let's band together to storm the child consultation centre!" took up a large chunk of time and got a bit repetitive

This review contains spoilers

7/10

so, the penultimate chapter. theres a lot to get into here. firstly, I WAS FUCKING RIGHT!!! I CALLED THAT BOTH THE FURUDES AND TAKANO HAD SOMETHING TO HIDE! I KNEW TAKANO WAS TELLING THE TRUTH IN TSUMIHOROBOSHI! Now, im still curious how rika got those syringes in a few chapters, but damn the consistency of foreshadowing all the way back in onikakushi with the mountain dogs rivals trail's consistency. great fucking writing. and everything just seems to fall into place with all the reveals. but. i have not mentioned the "main" scenario of this arc, ive only mentioned my reactions to the "epilogue/prologue"(to episode 8), and with good reason. i mean... it was more interesting than the water gun fight or other sol segments that bloat higurashi, but overall it was extremely dragged out(i just kinda skimmed the night before watanagashi scene, looking up every now and then, and 45 minutes coulda been summed up in 5.), and teppei was more comically evil than in any other higu episode. at least in tsumihoro, he had like a whole badger game thing going on, but here it's just super "im evil hahahahaahaahaahaah" kinda deal. which sure, in tatari, he was kinda like that but it was fresh, and we got the murder plot to make up for it. here it just recycles and adds nothing new to it. and, ill say that the """"""funny"""""""""" """""""gags"""""" with satoko are extremely uncomfortable and not funny in the slightest, their just creepy and weird. that 15 minute scene in angel mort was just gross to sit through, and i ended up skipping it.(like most of the sol segments, get trolled) but bottom line, i enjoyed the start, and the end to this arc. so, 2/3rds. ill say that the saving satoko part was the most interesting not necessary addition yet, but it was still pretty boring. since im taking that into account, i think im gonna have to give it a 7/10. it wasnt as consistent as tsumihoroboshi or meakashi, but the setup to the final episode was pretty fucking great, if a bit dragged out after the credits sequence. but if ep.8 entirely focuses on this part of the story, i can see it knocking meakashi off the throne of favorite arc. with all that taken into account, along with the unnecessary gross stuff about satoko, thats why im giving it a 7/10.

to the final episode, after which i will finally be free from 07th expansion prison, at least until i start umineko(oh no!).
1-meakashi
2-tsumihoroboshi
3-tatarigoroshi
4-onikakush
5-minagoroshi
6-watanagashi
7-himatsubushi

This review contains spoilers

This might be the least subtle thing I've ever read and that's okay.
The theme of "talk to your friends instead of self isolating when you have problems" is constantly present and is super well represented. There are very few stories where I think a political activism arc is a sensible plot point, but it fits in perfectly here thanks to the buildup from previous episodes and, again, the central theme.
The trapped in a time loop bit was also very well done. Despite the circumstances it was extremely easy to relate to Rika's situation and to draw parallels with depression, and the talking to and working alongside friends to beat "fate" was incredibly good.
Hinamizawa Syndrome, while a bit out of nowhere, is also a very direct anti-isolation metaphor.
The only reason I don't have this at a perfect score is because I think the plot twist at the end was kinda bad. For a story set in a small town, having the true culprit's main weapon be a private army of goons with no personality coming all the way from Tokyo feels anticlimactic. A complete tonal shift that wasn't foreshadowed particularly well and feels completely removed from everything else in the novel about small town life and interpersonal interactions.