The beauty of Super Monkey Ball 1&2 is that they're perfectly designed. When you fail in the originals, you know it was your fault and you want to keep playing to get better and learn the best routes. This game is piss-easy until about world 8. Then with a wonky game feel, bad level design, and weird physics all mixed together, you feel no accomplishment when you succeed and you never feel like it was your fault when you fail. 10-5 is one of the worst designed levels I have ever experienced. Generally, there feels like there is 0 consistency with the hazards on every level. For example, sometimes you need to use boost pads to clear the stage, other times they are there to kill you, and sometimes a level will have both and trial-and-error is the only way to find out which you should use. That's just bad design. Also the party games are complete trash and they drastically reduced the quantity from the Wii game...not that the missing ones were any good anyway. At least you can play as Sonic...so there's that I guess.

Oh boy, there's a lot of monkey business going on here, and in the worst way possible. This is by far one of the least enjoyable experiences I have ever had playing a video game, and frankly I think has destroyed any interest in the entire Monkey Ball franchise for me. The game is fucking awful, one of the worst designed things I have ever had to deal with, and this comes from someone who's played awful I Wanna be the Guy Fangames purposely made to piss off the player. I didn't even know I could get as angry as I did when playing this, and now while writing this I have a pretty strong headache.

The problem with this game, is that it starts pretty enjoyable, but then at some point immediately stops being so. It has a chill friendly vibe for the first five worlds, but then at Cobalt Caverns it becomes completely unenjoyable and irredeemable trash. This is a AAA game and I have to deal with bad cycles in the platforming as if it was made by a complete amateur. Difficulty is increased without rarely any sort of innovation, it instead just spams narrow rails to go on for the majority of the level, or some other aspect that is both long and tedious. Even by the last world, it still utilizes the bounce rods to be only annoying to the player with them in the middle of the way to go. Interesting design is ruined by the necessity of difficulty, such as spinning hamster wheels that on their own would be fun, but instead there's a chain of them you need to jump between. It frankly feels like half of the game was abandoned by the actual developers, and instead a group of company interns decided to take over the project and ruin it without any sense of thoughtfulness just so the final worlds feel difficult.

Certain design choices also feel rather unusual for a game like this, and become especially annoying after a while. The lack of a dedicated camera control system is obsessively obnoxious, while you can move your perspective by moving the monkey itself, it's completely unreasonable for the game to lack actual camera controls. Also, before every single attempt you have to wait for a camera pan over the stage, whilst this might be desired for your first viewing, it simply becomes pretty annoying when you just want to restart as quick as possible.

Minigames are the other side of the game, and while some of them are pretty interesting, there's a lot of failed execution in them as well. Games such as the sliding or ice ring include some of the most awkward controls possible, with others like skydiving or the ball throw having their own strange nuances that make them unenjoyable. Even the space shooter game, which could be really fun, is partially ruined by the fact your ship moves with some weird momentum left and right. One aspect about the Decathlon mode that I found rather annoying is that for one achievement you actually have to finish it 36 times, meaning 360 minigames, what a drag.

Overall, this game was probably one of the worst things I've ever played, and frankly I'm pretty disappointed. I truly have no idea if I'll ever play another monkey ball game again because of this, it has truly ruined any hope for the series that I had.

I feel so bad for anyone who picked this up as there first game in the series, and thinks this is what Monkey Ball is. Through the first few worlds I was like, “oh this isn't THAT bad, it’s kinda just an easier version of the originals”. How wrong I was. As I kept going on, I hated and hated the game more and more. I despise this game. As a kid I played 2 a lot, it was a tough game but I managed fine and got decent at it. This is not a Monkey Ball game though. This is a 3d platformer, disguised as a Monkey Ball game. Monkey Ball games are Physics games, not 3D platformers. If I wanted to play a 3D platformer with god awful controls, a bad camera and slippery physics, I would have asked.The simple addition of a jump button changes everything, no longer are you trying to tilt the stage to gain momentum to pull off fun and addictive trick shots. Your slowly hopping around these boringly designed levels and fighting the controls not to fall off while platforming. I hate the final boss too, I spent like an hour trying to beat him legitimately and he would randomly just reach over unintentionally and knock me off the stage, even playing as the smallest character Baby. I had to resort to cheesing him by camping underneath him were he couldn't touch me and killing him from there. He’s ugly and stupid and I hate him so much. 1 and 2 were addictive, fun, creative arcade style physics games that were challenging, yet addictive because they were designed that way, to be quarter munchers. The player would get experimental and try different things to reach a goal, it such a great formula. This just makes me want to turn off my switch, because I wasn't having any fun during “challenging” stages. I hate this game so much. Besides all that, as far as the remaster goes, the new additions are nice, I guess. The song is catchy and the yellow and black visuals are sleek. Too bad its layered onto such an unfixable, deeply flawed game.

It's a fine enough title. Doesn't quite live up to the fun that Super Monkey Ball 2 had seeing as the story mode of this game is a bit lacking. I also found the game less difficult than other titles due to the jumping ability, which was useful in being able to correct mistakes that I wouldn't have been able to otherwise, but it also made several maps far easier for me to complete. I haven't tried out the party games yet but I intend to once I have a group of people to play them with. The graphics are tight as one would hopefully expect from a game made in 2019.

Thoughts on it are the same as Banana Blitz but I'll elaborate a little further here: extremely boring level design where you're usually just laid down on tracks, boss levels are horrible (not fun, not hard persay but time consuming and easy to randomly get thrown off the level and you have to restart the whole boss fight) and the control feels floaty and not good. I also found myself fighting the camera often. I hate the inclusion of the jump mechanic and the fact that levels are designed around it. Minigame selection is also not good. I didn't dabble in the "online" mode at all but I imagine it's nothing special. I guess this game is ever so slightly better than its Wii counterpart because you aren't forced into shitty motion controls.

I bought this game on sale for $10 and installed a mod which replaces the OST and announcer with the Wii version's. Banana Blitz HD has gorgeous audiovisual design! I like that you can short-hop your jumps, really makes the game feel more responsive. I don't think you could do that on the Wii. Playing this game with a GCN controller makes me feel like I'm playing Super Monkey Ball!

Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz has level design which doesn't compliment its controls or physics. Levels range from bland to confusing. Often levels will have winding paths, which, if you try to simply roll up the path, the monkey will roll off the side (Space Case 7). There are times when the level is a straight line with boost panels leading up a ramp, and the monkey will simply not clear the jump or miss what the path seemed to lead the jump to (Volcanic Pools 1, 8). Some levels are completely made up of winding paths with boost panels, with a short time limit, requiring players to speed through to make it to the goal in time, but, because we're playing Super Monkey Ball here, the monkey often simply rolls off the side, no matter how much you fight it. So, you can't enjoy going fast, because you have to slow down to not fly off the stage, but you can't go too slow, or you'll run out of time. It is a challenge, but it feels like the challenge is fighting against the game's physics instead of mastering them. There are obstacles and enemies in this game to impede progress and present a challenge, but the jump is so powerful, you can simply jump over everything dangerous. I almost feel more secure in the air than on the ground. This game features thin, winding platforms which require precision to roll across(Volcanic Pools 2), but they weirdly don't build up to it, and the first level which has them, Cobalt Caverns 5, is a rough introduction, because the path tits downwards slightly and turns sharply. Banana Blitz has boss battles, in which the player waits patiently for the enemy to make itself vulnerable, then they bop them on the head. The bosses feel incomplete, because the octopus boss lets the player clip into its tentacles and hit him for free, and the final boss will knock the player off the stage with the windups of his attacks more than his actual attacks. I also think that half the bosses KOing the player instantly isn't a very interesting gameplay situation, especially when they're already so bad at conveying their own danger (despite having a giant arrow over their hot pink weak point).

It's so strange that the level design in this game is so weak, because every ten levels, there will be a level which feels like a Super Monkey Ball level, a level which actually compliments the gameplay(Pirate's Ocean 3). I can tell that the developers were thinking about what they had, because certain levels reuse concepts from earlier levels, with the spiral towers and the wire-path platforms, but none of it comes together.

Still, the gwaphix are so pwetty, so I got a kick out of this game, while I was on my Monkey Ball kick. As a Super Monkey Ball fanatic, I've been tempted to get this game for a while, despite knowing exactly what it is, so now that I've played it, I don't have to be tempted anymore. SEGA's releasing a remake of Deluxe, which I should vibe to, but I certainly don't trust them to design new levels, if they decide to make an actual, new game. That hypothetical, future Super Monkey Ball game will have to stand up on its own merits.

Super Monkey Ball is a very dear series to me, I've played a lot of SMB 1 & 2 as a child back in the GameCube days, and for some reason I never got to play Banana Blitz on the Wii, and I am hyped for Banana Mania, saw this on sale and decided to give it a try, and well this game is just... frustrating. As the first game in the series to add the jump ability, I don't think this helps at all in the design of the stages, and it's weird cause I tought the game is good up until world 4, then the rest is just hell, the bosses are not fun either. But one thing I liked is that you can strategize because characters have different stats, the stage has thin platforms? Choose Baby and you'll have an easier time, GonGon bigger size and weight helps not falling for certain platforms and so on. I also didn't like finding out they replaced the soundtrack with a new one in this HD version, even if the new one isn't exactly bad I'd like the original experience. The game has character skins that you unlock just by playing normally and I appreciated this very much, but in conclusion, most of the stages are not fun and the designed with just thin platforms for you to fall off and the physics are very bumpy, making it extremely frustrating. If you want to play a Monkey Ball game, just wait for Banana Mania and I'm sure you'll have a better time;