I enjoy when a game lives up to it's hype. God of war does so many things the right way that some of the flaws (which it has not many) have little to none weight.
I enjoyed the story, the gameplay and most of the world.
I'm glad that it is not filled with stupid fetch quests. Almost every quest feels rich and adds at least to the worldbuiling or father/son relationship.

But to be a 5* game it should have been more impactful to me. It is great but it is not perfect. I'm looking forward to Ragnarök!