HarperMeows
2011
2017
A fun throwback to Sonic's heyday. Developed by Evening Star, Headcannon, and PagodaWest Games, Sonic Mania has a lot of talented staff working on it, some with over a decade of experience with ROM hacking and fan games. Their talent shows in how great the level design is and how fun Sonic is to control! On top of that, these developers are hardcore fans, and there's tons of references, easter eggs, and other callbacks to the series as a whole sprinkled throughout. The excellent music by Tee Lopes is the cherry on top to make this one of the best platformers out on the market right now. I highly recommend Sonic Mania!
2022
A not-so-great collection of some of Sonic's best outings. Filled with random bugs, errors, inconsistencies, extremely low quality audio, and other glaring flaws, I do not recommend this to anyone. That is, in its unmodded state. The amazingly talented modding community for Sonic has gone the extra mile to actually make Origins one of the best ways to play these games, fixing a vast majority of these bugs and inconsistencies. If you want to play this collection, make sure to get Sonic Origins Ultrafix! As this is a review of the base product, I sadly cannot include Ultrafix as part of the rating. The base product as-is, even after all of its updates, remains a laughably bad rerelease. I do not recommend.
2015
2016
2024
2017
Fun fighting game with a mediocre story. The only story modes you need to play are Margaret's P4A story and Labrys's P4A story. The rest are kind of bland with an occasional funny moment or two. As a fighting game it's extremely fun an addictive. Feel free to ignore the story mode and have a fun time playing online with friends.
2022
Fantastic game. I absolutely love the 32-bit aesthetic! The game controls well, the movement is fun, and there's a lot of replay value, whether it be mastering the game's movement to get good times, or getting all of the collectibles. The little bits of lore are neat too. There's also cute designs and a fantastic soundtrack to boot! I highly recommend this game!
2011
An excellent game! Amazing graphics and music (at least in the Japanese version). While the level design is less traditional than other platformers, it emphasizes exploration and experimentation. Learning where the Robot Teleporters are, learning the different pathways through the levels, and speedrunning the levels with that knowledge is really fun! This game has a lot of charm and I highly recommend it!
2017
2022
An unpolished mess that attempts to mimic a AAA game. While this game does try to do good things, all of those good things are undermined by the general lack of direction, lack of cohesion, and lack of any quality control. If I wasn't falling through the floor every 5 minutes, I was finding an extremely boring and/or tedious puzzle to waste time with. Nothing in this game feels good. Sonic's movement is extremely stiff, he constantly gets stuck in the floor, his speed resets when you jump, and there's no sense of flow at all. Combine this with a very boring story filled to the brim with needless references and you have a mediocre experience. If this is a "first step in the right direction" as fans say, then I'm not looking forward to what this series has in store for the future.