Tim 2018 GOTY - Frank agreed
Brandon refuses to nominate a game from 2018

Alex 2017 GOTY

Frank 2017 GOTY

Tim's nomination for GOTY 2019 - but says there is no GOTY 2019 because of an old Kotaku video he made.

Brandon's half-hearted 2019 GOTY due to not wanting to play it on PC - only playing a couple hours of it at time of recording.

Tim 2017 GOTY

Frank's half-hearted 2019 GOTY recommendation

Brandon 2017 GOTY

Frank's joke nomination for 2018 GOTY