More refreshing than Dark Souls III, yet still too familiar. Some really great bosses in a sea of lame ones. Too many sword fight bosses.

I appreciate that they took a unique direction with the story and characters. It didn't really pay off, but it's admirable to say the least. This has the best gameplay in a Naughty Dog title by far. Overall, it's worth playing if you liked the original, but it won't change your mind otherwise.

Wonderful world and characters. Fantastic exploration and filled to the brim with checkboxes to tick off.

Unique concept, good execution, okay narrative. Wish it was a bit longer.

Great gameplay, atmosphere, and world. Lame, disappointing narrative.

Solid characters stuck in a pretty cookie-cutter narrative. The wolf man is hot, as he should be.