Characters:Probably the strongest point of the game,is really interesting how this community handles the tragedies that happen in the game and how this affects eveyone including the protagonist,even though i think that are definetly some characters better than other i think tha they all work best togheter instead of individually,individually you have a lot of mid with some characters shining,but togheter it covers most the characters lack of develoment and screen time since we are seeing a community not a specific characer,but if i have to choose one t will be the protagonist andreas,i think he is just the one that is the most interesting,has the most develoment and has the most screentime
Character tier list:https://tiermaker.com/list/video-games/pentiment-characters-1409554/3041229

The story,even though there is some nonsense on the ending of the final act i still think is a decent ending,and the story itself is really entertaining and we see a little of everything,but is mostly about beliefs,relationships and legacy,every person is religious and since is a little town everybody knows everybody,for this even the small things become big,and most of things are about religion since the town is mostly based in religion,and even in the badtimes we are to set a legacy for the future to folow and gain advice on what and to what not to do,and in this story even in this little ass town there is a fair amont of adventure and mistery,something about this place seems magical you go there and it changes your life,but overall i think that the story is really good

The graphics/aesthetics are amazing in this book like story its really unique and it all makes sense in the end

i dont have a lot of negatives other than the pacing in some places,lack of content and character develoment and some plot holes

Overall,really interesting story about a fictional place that shows how it affects its characters,and even its not perfect its still really good
Decent 8