In the list of GOATs, RDR 2 earns its place primarily because of its plot and the character of Arthur Morgan. This game is not perfect, because Rockstar continues to replicate their outdated game design. I don't blame them for it, this type of games are selling well and will likely do so for a long time to come. It's a must-play for everyone, not much more to say. It's simply an astonishing piece of art. Greatest character in a video game of all time, period. I cried, I cried a lot…

Dark Souls isn't a perfect game; the second half feels rushed. But the first blind playthrough until Anor Londo is something that I never felt before. It's a 3D Metroidvania mixed with an Action RPG, absolute generational masterpiece, one of the GOATs. It's so deep and good that it hurts. I played it during the looong nights of isolation times of COVID, and this game taught me that I could never stop fighting against depression and the real-life demons. If I raised the white flag, I would turn hollow, but I didn't dare to do it...

To me, it's the best From Software game. They've rectified all past errors and enhanced it even further. It's the only game from the company with a real good storytelling, the others are either mediocre or poor. Nothing much to say, straight Masterpiece!

It's the definitive From Software experience. I never felt so good grinding on a RPG. One of the GOATs.

This game was made with such amount of love, that it's visible even to naked eyes. Geralt is absolutely phenomenal. As for the DLCs, OMG, there are no words—they simply enhances furthermore an already perfect game. A must-play for everyone!

This game left me completely astonished. Blew me away. It feels like it could have been scripted by H.P. Lovecraft, an absolutely fantastic storytelling experience. It's so refreshing and innovative, offering the PERFECT experience of a detective game. Every aspect of the game design has been meticulously crafted down to the last detail; it's simply amazing. Two nominations at the Game of the Year awards were not enough; it deserved more recognition.

Ryū ga Gotoku is the game Rockstar wanted to make, but unfortunately they don't understand enough about game design to do it with GTA. How in the world could I have never heard of Yakuza 1? I didn't know a beat 'em up game could be so good. I know the studio had low expectations for this new IP in the release date, but even after 19 years later, the game remains magnificent.

The devs and writters care for the plot and the setting is jaw-dropping! Sega made a game that seems like a lot of fun to being a member of the organized crime. Kamurochō is the ultimate experience of what Tokyo's center should be like. So much cultural wealth, neon signs, yakuza dogmas, tattoo meanings, just magnificent. Fantastic representation. The plot is extremely dramatic with good twists, like if The Godfather had been filmed in Japan.

Combat is heavy and slow, but it reminds me of From Software games in a way; smashing buttons will be highly punitive, so you have to predict your rival next move and be assertive. Resident Evil 4 was definitely the game of the year in 2005, but I believe Yakuza is good as God of War and Shadow of The Colossus. Phenomenal. The only REALLY bad thing about Yakuza 1 is the camera during combat, dreadful, it almost ruined the combat experience in the last quarter of the game.

ps: played Kristian Zdunek's Restored version with PCSX2 settings as indicated by him. Phenomenal work, the Japanese dubbing is very solid. I can't say anything about the original NTSC version.

1 star for minor improovements on manager career mode. Everything else: TRASH! Nice cash grab game. This bad boy crashed a lot on my PC, don't know why.