Reviews from

in the past


Only played it once, unlike PM and TTYD which I've done repeat playthroughs of, but I really enjoyed my sole playthrough of this. Don't think the gameplay holds up, especially compared to the last 2 games, but hands down the best story out of the bunch. Best characters too, this game got a surprising amount of laughs out of me. Still can't believe Intelligent Systems/Nintendo actually came up with that whole Francis encounter.

gameplay's kinda meh but the story's really good

I feel like this game had a great impact on my sense of humor and I'm not sure if that's a good or a bad thing

A lot of people don't like this game because it's a platformer, but I think it's just as good as the other Paper Mario games. The writing, the storytelling, the characters, the gameplay, this game is so well crafted. If you've written this one off for being different from it's prequels, I urge you to give it a chance, you wont regret it.

Super Paper Mario é um spin-off brutal da série Paper Mario. Aproveita tão somente a estética para entregar um jogo de plataforma mesclando perspectiva 2D e 3D de maneira extremamente criativa, mas destruindo o que fez da franquia algo memorável.

Desde este jogo, a Nintendo perdeu a mão com a franquia, com inovações que não mantiveram a qualidade dos antecessores.


This was the first Paper Mario game I ever played, and if I had never played TTYD it would be a full 5. Considering this game on its own away from the other Paper Mario games it's actually still a 5. I think people shit on this game too much for not having a turn-based battle system and having too much platforming. The 2D-3D gameplay is pretty fun and the characters and story are all worth experiencing. There are a couple of bum chapters and the backtracking padding is horrid upon replaying, but if you're just looking to play the game once and say you've played "the first bad Paper Mario game", then you'll have to play Sticker Star afterwards, because this is not a bad Paper Mario game.

Shiggy Miyamoto got me up in here crying about a butterfly.

Only experience with Paper Mario, haven't played it in years but it has some really creative locations and level designs. Also the story's okay too

Super Paper Mario probably has one of the best stories to ever come out of a Mario game. Good spin on the platforming genre and gave a nice blend of RPG elements. Despite it being the penultimate downfall of the Paper Mario series, it still holds up very well and isn't held back by the fact that it's different. Creates unique characters and dialogue that are very enjoyable. Mr. L for smash.

The greatest story ever told in a Mario Game paired with some extremely boring and basic gameplay that ensures that it doesn't quite work as a platformer or an rpg.

A lot of people out here disrespecting what is probably the single greatest Mario game ever made, a real shame.

I might need to give it another shot but it was a "worst of both worlds" kind of game for me and killed Paper Mario in my eyes. I doubt I would hold the same opinion if I played it today, but it's a very low priority.

better than ttyd. do not yell at me

this game is tied to an ex best friend of mine which sucks but i like it tho

crick
crack
MIMIMIMIMIMIMIMIMIIIII

Genre-shift into a Westone style action game... Without the brisk pacing and satisfying combat. Game is way too verbose for its own good.

Super Paper Mario is a weird clash of genres. In some ways it feels as though it's at war with itself. The story interrupts the gameplay, and the gameplay interrupts the story. It manages to be fun and memorable despite that. The series charm is mostly intact, though the world and its denizens aren't nearly as interesting as the previous RPG entries, but that's to be expected. This game is a sore spot for many fans, as the shift in genre really wasn't asked for, and the familiar, beloved style of TTYD has yet to return.

Superb tongue in cheek writing with lots of funny moments. It can get surprisingly dark without ever having tonal dissonance, has some of the most interesting characters in a Nintendo game, and displays tons of creativity in both the writing and aesthetic.

Sadly it plays like a mediocre puzzle platformer with some RPG elements mixed in. It generally lacks any interesting gameplay situations and doesn't really do anything with the central mechanic of switching between 2D and 3D. Ultimately the gameplay holds it back from reaching the heights of its predecessors, in spite of the great writing.

Why they got rid of the turn based combat? The story was good tho.

Best Paper Mario game. Fite me.

Paper, Mario. Mario, Paper. Such a stupid concept. Why in the actual hell would someone like this game. I mean, I understand why someone would like this game, wait no I don't. I had a friend that liked this game, and let's just say we aren't friends anymore.

This game is so fantastic. It has amazing charm and it’s unique and a great experience to play. Best story in any Mario Game. Also this game does side scrolling really well.

the most boundary pushing, tightly written and experimental of the mario games of any kind, unsurprisngly, nintendo also hates this game


A great story with uninteresting, easy gameplay and some heavy padding. Still an overall fun experience.

great game, i have no desire to ever play it again

Luigi becomes a goth villain and we see mario in hell.